Private institutional investor capital in the world amounts to $147 trillion. Much of this amount is located in developed markets and Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries alone account for $84 trillion. Institutional investors commonly have little exposure to emerging markets and long-term infrastructure financing projects, possibly due to the scarcity of appropriate investment opportunities. Leveraging this capital remains a challenge. However, addressing this issue has sparked a recent growth in new and innovative financial solutions.
In developed and emerging markets, green bonds have been receiving significant attention from policy makers, issuers, and investors. Green bonds or climate bonds are bonds earmarked to encourage sustainability and to support climate-related or other special environmental projects. Green bonds finance projects aimed sustainable water management, the deployment of environment-friendly technologies, increasing energy efficiency, pollution control, the protection of aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems, clean transportation, sustainable agriculture, and fisheries and forestry.
For example, recently the European Union (EU) took significant steps in setting up an EU Green Bond Standard. Given that emerging markets nations are bearing the brunt of the impact of climate change, the emerging markets should be the hub of green bond activity. However, the mobilisation in emerging markets has not taken off at the same level as in other markets, and investors are not very aware of relevant investment opportunities.
International Finance Corporation of the World Bank (IFC) offers a holistic approach to the development of green bonds as an issuer, investor, provider of advisory services, technical assistance and risk mitigation instruments to create and develop the green bond market. Jean Marie Masse chief investment officer, financial institutions, IFC speaks exclusively to International Finance about the IFC’s active role in promoting the green bond market and the challenges and solutions for promoting green bonds in emerging markets.
How do green bonds fit into IFC’s climate strategy?
In accordance with its Climate Implementation Plan, IFC is now helping clients to issue their own green bonds. There is also opportunity to create new aggregation models through IFC’s work with financial institutions, including green bonds. IFC will also support green bond issuances of its manufacturing, agribusiness, and commercial services clients, targeting those who have made public climate-related commitments.
This support can be in the form of direct investment in green bonds or through IFC’s partial credit guarantees that can accompany a bond, which, among other benefits to the issuer, will guarantee payment to bondholders up to a specified amount. This provides emerging market clients with access to a wider investor base and paves the way for future issuances without enhancement.
While green bonds can support a range of climate-related activities, they are an ideal aggregation tool to finance IFC clients’ energy efficiency improvements. As one of the leading issuers of green bonds, IFC and the World Bank have helped to develop the standards for green bonds issuance. IFC works with financial institutions to issue their own green bonds, enabling banks to further develop green financing.
IFC offers a holistic approach to the development of green bonds: we are an issuer, investor, provider of advisory services, technical assistance and risk mitigation instruments to create and develop the green bond market.
Since launching the Green Bond Programme in 2010, IFC remains one of the world’s most prolific issuers of green bonds. In 2013, IFC was the first issuer to list a billion-dollar green bond in the global market. The largest green bond ever issued at the time. This was heralded as a landmark transaction that proved green bonds as a mainstream product. To date, IFC has issued around 150 green bonds in 16 currencies amounting to almost $10 billion.
IFC has played a key role in developing the market infrastructure needed to promote the product in a number of ways such as the establishment of the Green Bond Principles (GBP) for which IFC has served as a member of the Executive Committee since its inception. The GBP are the most accepted guidelines for the issuance and reporting of green bonds globally. In addition, on impact reporting, IFC was instrumental in co-drafting the initial Harmonised Framework for Impact Reporting, a template for issuers to use as a basis for their impact reporting. This document remains the basis for most public issuer reporting.
IFC channels investments through financial institutions such as commercial banks to support climate-related credit lines. Since 2005 IFC has worked with more than 180 institutions in 61 countries through 219 climate projects, providing $9.8 billion in long-term financing from its own-account and in core mobilisation.
Over the last two years, IFC has helped nine banks and non-bank financial institutions issue green bonds worth $1 billion – all of which were first-time green bond issuances.
As a mobiliser of green bonds, IFC is taking the lead in deploying innovative ways to mobilise private capital to fill the financing gap required to tackle climate change. For example, the Amundi Planet EGO Fund, the world’s largest green bond fund in emerging markets, was launched in February 2018.
The fund, managed by Amundi, will ultimately invest in emerging market green bonds issued by financial institutions. It was closed at $1.42 billion, with a $256 million investments from IFC, and is expected to deploy $2 billion in green bonds over its seven-year investment period. The fund aims to increase the capacity of emerging market banks to fund climate-smart investments and increase the scale and pace of climate finance in emerging markets.
Through the IFC-facilitated Sustainable Banking Network (SBN), IFC shares green bond expertise and supports financial sector regulators and industry associations in emerging markets to develop green bond frameworks and catalyse local issuances. Established in 2012, SBN represents 36 countries and over $43 trillion in banking assets in emerging markets.
IFC also supports capital market regulators in the development of national green bond frameworks, and then socialises these funding instruments with other players (notably issuers, but also investors, second opinion providers, auditors) to support first green bond issuances in regional markets. This work in turn facilitates the development of green bonds as a new funding instrument for the financing of climate transactions, including renewable energy infrastructure, energy efficiency measures, green buildings and climate smart agriculture, thus expanding the range of available funding sources for climate projects.
In addition, to boost the supply of green bonds in emerging markets, IFC set up the Green Bond Technical Assistance Program (GB-TAP), a crucial addition to the EGO Fund. GB-TAP, which is financed by Switzerland, Sweden and Luxembourg, and provides advisory services on green bond issuances and impact reporting in line with the Green Bond Principles.
The IFC GB-TAP is an innovative approach in supporting the mobilisation of financing for green investments and expanding the capacity for green financing and issuance of green bonds to a considerable number of new emerging markets. Over its seven-year time span, the GB-TAP intends to create and accelerate the growth of the green bond asset class in emerging markets through broad market creation activities (such as training, research, dissemination of best practices and case studies, development of templates for green bond impact reporting and information disclosure) and targeted local capacity building. The objective of the programme is to develop the green bond market and build a bigger pool of green bond issues
In March 2019, IFC began offering its investment clients the option of structuring loans in accordance with the GBP. The principles, which are modelled on the GB, specify how loan proceeds should be used and projects selected in order to qualify for green-loan status. This can help businesses attract additional financing and enhance their reputation among shareholders, clients, and communities.
What more does IFC intend to do as part of its emerging market bonds strategy in future?
IFC intends to work on model green bond transactions issued by emerging market issuers, release market research reports to disseminate information about the opportunities in green finance in emerging markets, and develop tools to communicate about it.
Mobilising public and private institutional investors to deploy billions of dollars in capital for climate investments is essential to alleviate the impact of climate change. The EGO Fund does just that: as the largest green bond fund in the world, the Fund is helping to scale climate finance in emerging markets.
What more needs to be done to make the share of green bond issuance in emerging markets larger in relation to the rest of the world?
IFC has identified a gap in the market: the absence of a global standard for the external review of green bonds. As a result, green bond investors often receive incomplete or incomparable information across their green bonds’ investments. The harmonisation of external reviews (including second opinions and other related services) aims to contribute to the development of accountability and quality standards for the green
One of the key concerns of green bond investors is the use of the proceeds. How good and reliable is the reporting on the use of proceeds in emerging markets?
The use of proceeds, as defined by the GBP, should be disclosed in the form of external reviews at the time of green bond issuances, and in the annual impact reports released by green bond issuers. IFC conducted a study to analyse the scope and quality of ESG data collected by leading ESG data providers. A summary of findings on market constraints identified by IFC is as follows:
ESG data providers use proprietary ESG scoring frameworks, which differ with respect to materiality, indicator selection and weightage. Each provider uses different definitions of materiality and varying methodologies to normalise this materiality across companies, such as a universal sustainability framework versus benchmarking issuers by industry or peer group. ESG data providers also use proprietary methods to aggregate and weight ESG factors for summary scores. These differences result in conflicting ESG analysis and scores.
ESG reporting standards and guidelines differ. Even when companies report on the same topics, the data they report may not be comparable. Without the ability to compare ESG performance, investors find it difficult to meaningfully integrate ESG data into investment decisions.
One of the key challenges that organisations operating in the green bonds space in emerging markets face is the capacity to manage E&S risks. How can this lack of capacity be overcome? What can governments, financial institutions, and companies do?
Indeed, there is often a capacity issue, at times it is just a market perception, for emerging markets bond issuers to disclose and manage E&S risks in a way which meets mainstream investors requirements. To address these constraints, IFC is undertaking the following holistic solutions to advance emerging market environmental, social and governance (ESG) data:
IFC has explored ways to encourage emerging market capital market issuers, including green bond issuers, to disclose material ESG performance indicators to drive greater investment in emerging market capital markets. This includes working with an ESG data provider to increase the scope of coverage of emerging market issuers as well as broadening the coverage of collected ESG indicators. IFC is seeking to identify ESG data providers to support with the collection and analysis of ESG information for emerging market issuers. IFC will use this information to benchmark emerging market issuers using its risk-weighted methodology.
IFC is also exploring ways to use artificial intelligence and machine learning to support ESG data collection and analysis. There are opportunities to complement IFC’s work with ESG data providers to expand coverage of emerging market issuers and widen real-time information collection. Possible areas for development include encouraging AI-ESG data providers to use existing platforms to analyse data from emerging markets through the lens of IFC’s ESG Performance Indicators.
Overall these efforts will play a key role in increasing market transparency and catalysing additional opportunities and investments in quality emerging market green bonds.